Matty's Musings - Pourovers of all shapes and sizes

Reading Time

I get asked often "So, how do you make your coffee?" I think folks often presume I have some kind of magical combination of expensive equipment to conjure really amazing coffee. That assumption isn't exactly wrong, I love my Gs3 and HG-one for making espresso, but I start every morning with a coffee made from a pourover.

I love the slow pace of pouring water over coffee. Some days I can get really excited about the details of how and where I'm pouring, while other days pouring water into the filter without spilling is all I can manage. 

There are a bunch of different shapes, sizes, materials and brands of pourovers. What gives? I'll take up a little bit of space on the internet and add to the pile of other folks that have mused on this subject. And maybe, just maybe, I can help to demystify all these different pourovers and which one might be the best for you. 

Don't want to read? Further down you will find a table with my opinions on the strengths and weaknesses of different pourovers and a breakdown of who each kind of pourover might be for. 

(my spell check isn't happy about the word "pourover" but I'm going to leave it as is. I like it better than "pour over." That feels like a different thing to me...)

Shape

Every pourover functions, essentially, the same way: add ground coffee to some kind of filter and the pour water over those grounds. The liquid will go through the coffee grounds and down into some kind of vessel. One of the big differences between all the different pourover options one could use is the shape of the business-area, and with that difference also comes the different shapes of filters.

Some brewers are shaped to allow pointy filters, others a wedge-like filter. Some use a flat bottom filter with rippled sides. These shape differences for me are all about surface area. A brewer using a pointy or wedge-like filter has an amount of coffee that is kind of the "right" amount because most of the water will have to go through that point. If too much water goes through the grounds in that point, that bit of coffee will be more extracted than the stuff at the top of brew bed. You don't want that! (unless you do... taste is subjective! You do you). That pointy filter shape also means the pourover-er should have some caution while pouring water over the coffee. If one hits the edge of the filter while pouring it could push some of the super fine coffee particles down to that point and really slow your extraction down. 

 

 

The surface area of a brewer using a flat filter will allow for more coffee to rest comfortably at the bottom without too much pileup. A flat shape lends itself to being able to brew way more coffee without over-extraction since one can make the grind size a little coarser with the introduction of more coffee and keep the same extraction %. Pretty cool, huh? You don't need to worry too much about hitting the edges of the filter here like the pointy filters, because there is nothing really to clog up in that flat shape. 

Flow Rate

How quickly the water (or maybe we should call it "coffee" at this point in the brewing process?) can get out of the brewer and into the vessel at the bottom is something to consider when getting to know a pourover brewer. 

Brewers that have a number of smaller holes that force everything to squeeze through will result in a cup that is more likely to have a heavier mouthfeel, while something that has unrestricted access to flow right on down will likely be a bit lighter in mouthfeel.


Mouthfeel is literally the weight or feeling of the coffee in your mouth. As you get lighter in mouthfeel, the trade will be more clarity of flavour. Have you ever seen one of those coffee flavour wheels? Or read some really strange and intriguing tasting notes on a bag of coffee? This is what I mean when I say clarity; To pick those flavours out easily.

Another aspect of the restricted flow rate v unrestricted flow rate is where water gets poured and its impact on the resulting cuppa. On a technical level where one is pouring water will ALWAYS matter and being even is "best" but I'll oversimply thing here a bit. I'd say that something with restricted flow rate kind of doesn't care how or where the water is poured. A brewer where the only thing impacting flow rate is the grind size of the coffee will be more greatly impacted by where that water goes for each pour.

Materials

Ceramic. Plastic. Stone. Metal. Pourovers are made from a bunch of different materials. Does it really matter which one you use? 

For me the answer to that question is more about personal preference, and lifestyle choices, rather than a large change in coffee quality for most folks. I'd suggest getting a brewer of the material and colour that you most

enjoy using and holding every day. But lets go there a bit and dig into why people preparing for Brewer's Cup might prefer one material over another. It comes down to heat.

For coffee extraction, higher temperature is more extraction, and a lower temperature means a slower or less extraction. If one is using a pourover made of metal, a potential impact of that choice is that the brewer will pull heat from the coffee in the brew bed, resulting in a lower temperature where the magic is happening. Something made of plastic will take less heat away in that ~3:00 minute brew. One thing folks can do with a metal/stone/ceramic brewer is to really wet the filter and thus heat up the brewer before the brewing process starts. 

Some Specifics and THE CHART

I've said some words about the shape of each brewer and their filters, the flow rate of the water from the pourover, and which materials are used in a general, kind of theoretical way. Now I'll discuss some actual brewers that we offer here at Roastoreum and distill what all means to me.

Below is a chart where I'll use 1-10 to show where each brewer falls in a few categories. 

  • Default grind size - Every recipe and each coffee will have a certain grind size that would be best, but I'll offer a rough estimate for each brewer. More flow rate for the brewer means finer grind size. The bigger the number the bigger the particle size. 
  • Mouthfeel - A bigger number is heavier mouthfeel. Smaller number means more tea-like
  • Clarity - Bigger number here has more clarity while a smaller number means more... muddled flavours
  • "Weekdayable" - How easy is this brewer to use on a weekday before rushing off for the day? A bigger number here is more easy to use while a smaller number here is maybe more tricky to get consistent results. Consider lower number brewers for the weekend maybe?
  • How much coffee can I make? - I'm going to say a number of "mugs". I hate "cups" as a measurement because it could mean anything, really. Are we talking cups of coffee? Liquid measuring cups? I'm just thinking most folks average, ~10-12oz mug. 
Brewer Name Default Grind Size Mouthfeel Clarity "Weekdayable" Mugs

Kalita Lotto 102 (extremely similar to a Melitta)

7 7 5 8 1.5
Kalita Wave 8 8 5 10 1-4
Hario V60 5 4 8 5 1
Origami Dripper (pointy) 5 4 8 4 1

Origami Dripper (flat)

7 6 8 7 1-4


Who is it for??

Each brewer has some qualities that make it the choice for someone so I'll walk through our pourover options and talk about a person in mind. Maybe you see yourself in one of these? 

Kalita Lotto (i.e Melitta Pourover) - This brewer is for someone that is probably just making one cup at a time, and maybe doesn't have regular access to a specialty coffee shop to buy filters from. Or they just prefer to get their coffee supplies from grocery store. You might like to put cream or sugar in your coffee so the added mouthfeel that this method offers is a plus for you. 

Kalita Wave - You just want consistent coffee. No frills (except for the ripples on the edge of the filter ;)).  You might also be someone that is making coffee for more than one someone(s) often. This brewer comes in a stainless steel option so you might be someone who wants to buy something once and not worry about it breaking down the road. You don't have or don't want a goose-neck kettle. 

Hario V60 - You love the idea of chasing that perfect cup of coffee. Every gram and second matters to you and you have a notebook where you keep all this data. You might like lighter roasted coffees with bright acidity and seek out every specialty coffee roaster you can while traveling. 

Origami Dripper - You might have access only to pointy filters for the V60 or flat filters used in the Kalita Wave so the option to use either one is quite convenient. Each filter brews the coffee totally differently too so you might be the kind of person that likes to be ready for any and all coffee-brewing-situations. You like pretty things and have strong preferences for certain shades of colour in your kitchen. You don't mind, or maybe even enjoy, that the brewer is made of two separate parts that could be purchased separately. 

Phew that was a lot

Pouring water over coffee grounds to get a warm delicious cup of coffee doesn't need to be super complicated. For those that want to understand what impacts a certain pourover might have on their cup of coffee, I hope that some of what is here helps to demystify that choice. 

As always... this post is written purely from the caffeine addled brain of one Matty Hawkins and no AI was used. These ideas and observations are my own.  



Back to blog